Note [Precise vs imprecise exceptions]
An exception is considered to be /precise/ when it is thrown by the 'raiseIO#' primop. It follows that all other primops (such as 'raise#' or division-by-zero) throw /imprecise/ exceptions. Note that the actual type of the exception thrown doesn't have any impact! GHC undertakes some effort not to apply an optimisation that would mask a /precise/ exception with some other source of nontermination, such as genuine divergence or an imprecise exception, so that the user can reliably intercept the precise exception with a catch handler before and after optimisations. See also the wiki page on precise exceptions: https://gitlab.haskell.org/ghc/ghc/wikis/exceptions/precise-exceptions Section 5 of "Tackling the awkward squad" talks about semantic concerns. Imprecise exceptions are actually more interesting than precise ones (which are fairly standard) from the perspective of semantics. See the paper "A Semantics for Imprecise Exceptions" for more details.
References 0
This Note does not link to any other.
Referenced by 3
- Precise exceptions and strictness analysis GHC.Types.Demand
- Bottom CPR iff Dead-Ending Divergence GHC.Types.Demand
- GHC.Types.Demand call site